Experience the magic of our Nutella Thumbprint Cookies – a delightful twist on a classic treat! These irresistible cookies combine the lusciousness of Nutella with the nostalgic charm of s’mores, creating a heavenly blend of flavors. With a gooey marshmallow center and a Nutella-infused cookie, each bite is a journey into sweet bliss. Save this recipe and treat yourself to a taste of indulgence!

Nutella s'mores cookies on a cookie sheet.

Nutella Cookies are the s’more-inspired cookies you didn’t even know you needed, but will never want to live without! They are made with graham crackers and marshmallows, like s’mores, then topped with a generous dollop of Nutella. The result? A chewy cookie that’s full of flavor and texture.

You won’t be able to resist these delicious s’more-inspired treats! So if you’re ready to experience a new take on s’mores, look no further than Nutella Cookies.

Ingredients

To make these sweet treats, you need the following ingredients:

butter
powdered sugar
an egg
vanilla
flour
salt
graham cracker crumbs
Nutella
Miniature marshmallows
cocoa

Instructions

To make them, you first need to make graham cracker crumbs. (I like to use a food processor.) Set them aside and then make the cookie dough.

Take 1 tablespoon of dough and form it into a ball. (I like to make all of my balls at once.) Then dip them, one at a time, in an egg white that has been whisked until frothy. After the egg white, roll each ball into graham cracker crumbs and then set them on a parchment-lined cookie sheet.

Next, take a dough ball and insert a finger – or thumb – into the middle to make a well. Then carefully try to press an indentation at the top to make the top part of the heart. Pull a little bit of the dough at the bottom to make it look like a point.

If you don’t want to make them heart-shaped, that is okay. Just make a well in the center.

Cookies with thumbprint impressions in the middle.

At this point, they are ready to go into the oven. Once they have baked, remove them and allow them to cool completely. (If the centers of the hearts have puffed up, gently push them back down before they start cooling.)

Jar of Nutella in front of a try of Nutella s'more cookies.

Then take Nutella and spoon a small amount into the center. It probably takes only about 1/2 a teaspoon.

Heart-shaped thumbprint cookies filled with Nutella.

Place 3 miniature marshmallows on top and place the cookies in the oven and set it for BROIL. Please do not leave the cookies unattended. Once the tops start to brown, remove them from the oven and all them to cool.

Heart shaped cookies filled with Nutella and topped with toasted marshmallows.

Once they have cooled you can drizzle a little chocolate on top.

Recipe Tip

If you want to make these for Valentine’s Day or any other occasion to say “I Love YOU!,” you can buy a bag of Jet-Puffed heart-shaped strawberry marshmallows and top the round thumb-prints with them. Aren’t they adorable?!

Thumbprint cookies filled with Nutella and topped with heart-shaped marshmallows.

Toast or not to toast – that is for you to decide.